October 12, 2018
Local Fix: Conference Season, Information Inequality, Digital, and Newspaper Week
Welcome to the Local Fix. Each week we look at key debates in journalism sustainability and community engagement through the lens of local news. But first, we always begin with one good idea…
One Good Idea: Too much of a good thing
This weekend our calendar runneth over with journalism gatherings. In Chicago, the Local Online Independent News Publishers are meeting (follow along at #LION18). In Mount Hood, Oregon, the Journalism and Women Symposium Conference and Mentoring Project (CAMP) is happening (follow along at #JAWSCAMP18). In Phoenix, Arizona, NewsGeist is bringing together journalists and technologists (follow along at #newsgeist). In New Haven, Connecticut, press freedom advocates are gathering for the Access and Accountability Conference being held at Yale Law School. In Washington, DC, the Double Exposure film festival combines investigative journalism with documentary film (follow along at #DXIFF). Democracy Fund is either sponsoring, funding, or attending these events and are grateful for the incredible people and work that are on display this weekend around the country. Did we miss an event? Tweet it and how to follow along from afar to @TheLocalNewsLab.
A new study from the Center for Cooperative Media found that in looking at a pool of 64 local online newsrooms, one of the key determinants of success was if the newsroom was located in a wealthy community. While it’s possible the move towards reader revenue will exacerbate this problem as newsrooms cater more to people who can pay, this study found that problem persists even for newsrooms who have successfully built a sustainable news business on local advertising. At the Online News Association conference last month, Heather Bryant moderated a related session on “journalism’s poverty problem“. All of this builds on important research from James Hamilton and Fiona Morgan on how information inequality tracks with economic inequality. At the Local Fix we see these issues as critical to discussions about the future of local news, and they have not always gotten the spotlight they deserve. Each of the articles below help move forward the conversation – how will you pick up the debate and bring it into your newsrooms and your community?
- Study: Successful online local news outlets often located in wealthy communities, and ads still pay the bills – Center for Cooperative Media
- How to report on — and hire for — journalism’s poverty problem – NiemanLab
- Poor Information: How Economics Affects the Information Lives of Low-Income Individuals – Fiona Morgan and James Hamilton
- “Known but not discussed”: Low-income people aren’t getting quality news and information. What can the industry do about it? – NiemanLab
The Digital Divide in Local News
In a report released last month, Jesse Holcomb takes a look at how local news is adapting to the digital age. “For many publishers, the internet is like an ill-fitting suit: functional, but not made for them,” writes Holcomb, “About one in ten local news outlets do not have a website.” So many of the debates about the future of news — from AI to blockchain — focus on a future that seems out of mind and out of reach for some local journalists. Four years ago, Mark Stencel, Bill Adair, and Prashanth Kamalakanthan found in similar research that money and time paired with infrastructure and culture were some of the biggest barriers to local newsrooms adopting digital reporting tools and practices. These points are echoed over and over again in reports from the Local Media Association, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, and others. In terms of how people are responding to these trends, organizations such asOpenNews and ONA are supporting local innovators across the country, and the solutions-oriented Table Stakes project is worth checking out. Thankfully, a number of the reports below highlight what’s working as well as what is not.
- Digital Adaptation in Local News – Tow Center for Digital Journalism
- The Goat Must Be Fed: Why Digital Tools Are Missing in Most Newsrooms – Duke Reporters Lab
- Report: Efforts at digital transformation feel ‘like mowing the yard when the house is on fire’ – Poynter
- The Digital Transition of Local News – Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism
Newspapers across the country celebrated the 78th annual National Newspaper Week, sponsored by the Newspaper Association Managers, a coalition of North American trade associations that serve the newspaper industry. Many newspapers and journalists used the occasion to share a look behind-the-scenes, and to take a step back and talk about why journalism is important for local communities. We especially appreciated those that, rather than lecturing people on why journalism is important, took the time to thank their readers and communities and open up conversations with the people they serve. Below we’ve shared just a few of the articles published this week.
- “Communities deserve to have a local paper: to hold officials accountable and maintain transparency, to inform parents what’s happening with the school district or at sporting events and to see what’s new in the community.” – The Creswell Chronicle
- “Maybe the ribbon cutting isn’t flashy enough to go viral, and the Thanksgiving turkey recipe is not going to change culinary trends across the nation. But these things, these small things in communities across the county and across the world, are what give meaning and purpose to all of our lives.”– Wisconsin Newspaper Association
- National Newspaper Week: A made-up holiday we can get behind – The Press Democrat
- “Our goal is to create a newspaper that the community sees itself in. We do it with each of you in mind. We thank our community, our readers.” – The Claremore Daily Progress
- “We wanted to put faces with the bylines and credits so you might recognize us as your neighbors, the people you see in church, in the grocery store and at many community events around Meridian and East Mississippi.” – The Meridian Star
The Local Fix is a project of the Democracy Fund’s Public Square Program, which invests in innovations and institutions that are reinventing local media and expanding the public square. Disclosure: Some projects mentioned in this newsletter may be funded by Democracy Fund, you can find a full list of the organizations we support on our website.